Scene 37 · Notes

Notes Scene 37: What Do You Make of It?

Notes on this scene

After Wilson leaves, Watson confesses that the case is completely obscure to him. Holmes argues that strange features often make a mystery simpler, while commonplace crimes are harder to distinguish from one another. Despite that confidence, he says that this particular affair requires prompt action.

Japanese in this scene

てしまう
The 〜てしまう form can show that an action is completed fully or that the result is regrettable or beyond control. Context determines which nuance is stronger.
のだ
のだ adds explanation or emphasis, similar to “the fact is…” or “it is that….” In polite speech it becomes のです or んです.
ほど
ほど expresses degree or an approximate extent: “to the point that; as much as; about.” The comparison in the sentence determines its natural English rendering.
は
は marks the topic of a sentence and can also set up a contrast with another item.

Full text: original English and Japanese translation

"Well, Watson," said Holmes when our visitor had left us, "what do you make of it all?"

「さて、ワトソン」客が帰ってしまうと、ホームズが言った。「きみはこの一件をどう思うね?」

"I make nothing of it," I answered frankly. "It is a most mysterious business."

「さっぱり分からないね」と私は正直に答えた。「なんとも不可解な話だよ」

"As a rule," said Holmes, "the more bizarre a thing is the less mysterious it proves to be. It is your commonplace, featureless crimes which are really puzzling, just as a commonplace face is the most difficult to identify. But I must be prompt over this matter."

「たいていの場合」とホームズは言った。「奇妙なことほど、かえって謎は浅いものなのだ。本当に頭を悩ませるのは、ありふれた、何の特徴もない犯罪のほうで、平凡な顔がいちばん見分けにくいのと同じことさ。だが、この件は急いで手を打たねばならない」

"What are you going to do, then?" I asked.

「それで、どうするつもりなんだい?」と私は尋ねた。

Japanese words in this scene (with English meanings; ☆ saves a word)

  • 件(けん) — matter; topic
  • 思う(おもう) — to think; to suppose
  • さっぱり — completely (with a negative); refreshingly
  • 私(わたし) — I; me
  • 正直(しょうじき) — honest; frank; candid; straightforward
  • なんとも — really; very; extremely; terribly
  • 不可解(ふかかい) — incomprehensible; mysterious; inexplicable; inscrutable
  • 話(はなし) — story; account

Next scene: A Three Pipe Problem

Holmes has explained that unusual cases may be shallow while ordinary crimes can conceal deeper difficulties, but he also says that they must act quickly. Watson asks what he intends to do next. The answer is unexpectedly simple: Holmes will smoke. He curls up in his chair, closes his eyes, and begins thinking in silence.